The short version
- Seasonal pricing fixes your winter budget and puts the weather risk on the contractor. Per-push pricing puts it on you.
- The Twin Cities average about 7.6 days a season with 2 inches or more of snow and 14.3 days with 1 inch or more. A 1-inch trigger means roughly twice the plow days of a 2-inch trigger.
- The range is wide: 1 to 16 days at 2 inches across 120 seasons. A per-push budget can swing by a factor of several from one winter to the next.
- Tiered seasonal contracts split the risk with a season-end bill or credit.
- Whatever the model, the scope decides the real price: walks, deicing, hauling, and return visits are where bids differ.
The four pricing models
| Model | How it works | Who carries the weather risk | Fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seasonal (flat) | One price for the winter, usually billed in equal monthly payments, whatever the snowfall. | The contractor. A heavy winter costs them, a light one costs you. | Fixed budgets: associations, multi-site portfolios, anyone who has to set a number before the season. |
| Per push (per event) | A price each time the site is serviced, often with brackets by snow depth. Deicing is billed per application. | The owner. You pay for exactly the winter you get. | Sites that can tolerate a variable bill, or that have reserves for a heavy year. |
| Tiered seasonal (hybrid) | A seasonal price tied to a snowfall band. If the season ends above or below the band, there is a bill or a credit. | Shared. | Owners who want a budget number and protection against overpaying in a light winter. |
| Time and materials | Hourly rates by equipment type plus materials by weight or volume. | The owner, entirely. | Unusual sites, hauling, and one-off work. Invoices are detailed and frequent. |
The Snow & Ice Management Association's guidance on per-event pricing is blunt about it: unless the winter is normal, one party wins and the other loses. Seasonal pricing does not remove that risk. It moves it to the contractor and prices it in.
What Twin Cities snowfall data says
The Minnesota DNR has counted daily snowfall in the Twin Cities across 120 seasons. These are the numbers that matter for a snow budget:
| Daily snowfall | Average days per season | Fewest | Most |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 inch or more | 14.3 | 3 | 27 |
| 2 inches or more | 7.6 | 1 | 16 |
| 4 inches or more | 2.7 | 0 | 8 |
| 6 inches or more | 1.2 | 0 | 5 |
In the DNR's words, "a plowable snowfall occurs in the Twin Cities roughly seven days per season," using 2 inches as the line. Normal seasonal snowfall at MSP is 51.2 inches on the 1991–2020 normals.
Two things follow. First, the average hides the spread: a per-push budget built on seven or eight events can face one event or sixteen. Second, the count is of calendar days, not service visits. A long storm can need two or three passes in one day, and days with a trace to an inch still need walks inspected and ice treated. Real visit counts run higher than these figures.
Trigger depth changes the math
SIMA's procurement standard defines trigger depth as "the agreed upon measurable amount of accumulated snow or ice wherein snow and ice management services will be dispatched." It is the single most important number in a per-push contract, because it decides how many times you are billed.
From the table above, moving a trigger from 2 inches to 1 inch roughly doubles the number of plow days in an average season, from about 8 to about 14. For a retail center or a medical office that cannot open on an inch of packed snow, that is the right answer and the budget should reflect it. For a warehouse yard with truck traffic and room to work, 2 inches may be fine.
Three questions to settle in writing:
- Where and how is depth measured? On site, or at the airport? By whom?
- Do walks and entries have a lower trigger than the lot? They usually should. People fall on sidewalks, not in drive lanes.
- What happens below the trigger? Ice, refreeze, and half-inch dustings cause more claims than blizzards. Decide whether deicing below the trigger is included, per application, or on call.
Our default commercial trigger is 1 inch for full-lot service, with walks and entries inspected at any measurable accumulation, and it is set per property at the site walk.
What is inside the price
Two seasonal bids for the same site can differ by a third and both be fair, because they cover different work. Before comparing numbers, confirm each bid says yes or no to:
- Sidewalks, entries, and stairs, including the public sidewalk if your city makes it yours. See sidewalk deadlines by city.
- Deicing: included, capped, or billed per application, and at what rate.
- Return visits for drifting, refreeze, and the berm city plows leave across aprons and ramps.
- Service during the storm, or only after it ends.
- Completion time relative to your opening hour or shift change.
- Stacking and hauling. Where piles go, and what triggers loading snow out. Hauling is almost always priced separately.
- A cap or blizzard clause on seasonal contracts: the snowfall total or storm size past which extra charges apply.
- Documentation: time-stamped service records and photos after each event.
How to choose
- If you set a budget once a year and cannot go back for more, as most associations and managed portfolios do, seasonal pricing is usually worth its premium. Multi-year terms with a defined escalator make it more predictable still.
- If you can absorb a heavy winter and would rather not pay for snow that does not fall, per push costs less in a light winter.
- If you want both, ask for a tiered seasonal price and look closely at where the bands sit against the 51-inch normal.
- If the site runs around the clock, long storms mean continuous service, and per-event invoices get hard to predict. Most 24-hour facilities choose seasonal.
We price both seasonal and per-event for any site, so you can compare them against recent Twin Cities winters before choosing. See commercial snow and ice management.