The short version
- Hardscape is the built part: patios, walks, walls, steps, edging. Softscape is the living part: trees, shrubs, perennials, lawn, and the soil and mulch they grow in.
- Hardscape costs more up front and little afterward. Softscape costs less to install and needs care every year.
- Build in this order: grading and drainage, walls, hard surfaces, irrigation, then plants and sod.
- In Minnesota, seed lawns from mid-August to mid-September and get evergreens in the ground before the end of October. Hardscape can be built any time the ground is not frozen.
- Many cities cap hard surface as a share of the lot, which sets a real limit on how much patio a yard can have.
What each term covers
| Hardscape | Softscape | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Patios, walkways, retaining walls, steps, driveways, edging, fire pits, boulders | Trees, shrubs, perennials, grasses, lawn, soil, mulch |
| What it does | Gives you level, dry places to walk and sit, and holds grade | Shade, privacy, color, cooling, and soaking up rain |
| Cost pattern | Higher up front, low afterward | Lower up front, ongoing care |
| How it ages | Looks best the day it is finished, then holds | Looks thin the day it is finished, then improves for years |
| Typical upkeep | Sweeping, joint sand, an occasional reset | Watering, pruning, weeding, mulch, replacement |
| Typical price | Paver patio $25–$45 per sq ft installed | Planting bed renovation $3,000–$10,000 |
Irrigation and lighting belong to neither group. They are the systems that run under and through both.
Getting the proportion right
A yard that is all hardscape is hot, glaring, and sheds every drop of rain. A yard that is all softscape has nowhere dry to put a chair. Most yards that feel finished use hardscape for the places people stand and sit, and softscape for everything they look at from there.
Three checks help when you are looking at a design:
- Size the patio to the furniture. A table for six needs about 12 by 14 feet to pull chairs out. Paving more than you will furnish is expensive and looks empty.
- Soften every hard edge you see from inside. A wall or patio edge with planting against it looks intended. A bare one looks unfinished.
- Check the city's hard-surface limit. Roofs, driveways, and patios all count. Apple Valley's limit on a typical lot is 35%, Savage's is 35% and drops to 25% near lakes and creeks, and Burnsville's is 25% within 1,000 feet of a lake. If you are close to the cap, the design has to trade patio for planting or use a permeable system. See permits and limits by city.
Which comes first
Hardscape, almost always. Building it means excavators, skid steers, and pallets of stone crossing the yard, and nothing planted survives that. The order that avoids rework:
- Grading and drainage. Decide where water goes before anything is built on top of it.
- Retaining walls. They set the finished levels for everything else.
- Patios, walks, and steps. Put sleeves under them for irrigation and lighting wire.
- Irrigation. Lines go in after the hard surfaces and before the plants.
- Trees first, then shrubs, then perennials. Largest to smallest.
- Sod or seed, then mulch. Last, so nothing drives over it.
The one exception is a large tree. If a design calls for one in a spot that equipment will not be able to reach once a wall is built, it goes in first.
Timing in Minnesota
Hardscape can be built whenever the ground is not frozen, which in a typical year means April into November.
Planting has narrower windows. University of Minnesota Extension puts the best time to seed a lawn between mid-August and mid-September, when soil is warm, nights are cool, and weeds are slowing down. Sod can go down through most of the growing season as long as it is watered. Container-grown trees and shrubs can be planted any time during the growing season if they are kept watered, and bare-root stock goes in during early spring before growth starts. Extension's one firm cutoff is for evergreens: do not plant them later than October. They keep losing water through their needles all winter and need roots in place before the ground freezes.
Pick plants for your zone. On the USDA's 2023 map the core cities and inner suburbs, Eagan included, are zone 5a, and many outer communities are still 4b. A shrub rated only to zone 5 is a gamble in a 4b yard, so check your ZIP code on the USDA map before buying.
New plantings also get a break on watering rules in most south-metro cities. Eagan exempts new sod, seed, and landscaping from its odd/even schedule for three weeks, and Lakeville and Rosemount for 30 days.
How to split a budget
There is no fixed ratio. A sloped lot may put most of the money into walls and drainage before a single plant is bought. A flat lot with a good patio already may be almost all planting. Two things hold in most projects:
- Spend on what cannot be redone cheaply. Base, drainage, and walls are expensive to fix later. Plants can be added every year.
- Do not strip the planting to afford more patio. Planting is the least expensive part of most projects and the part that makes the hardscape look like it belongs.
For current numbers, see what landscaping costs in the Twin Cities. For how we put the two together, see landscape design, hardscaping, and planting design.
Common questions
Is mulch hardscape or softscape?
Is a retaining wall hardscape?
Should I do hardscape or softscape first?
When is the best time to plant in Minnesota?
- University of Minnesota Extension: seeding and sodding home lawns
- University of Minnesota Extension: planting and transplanting trees and shrubs
- USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map (2023)
- University of Minnesota Extension: new plant hardiness zone map
- City of Savage: impervious surface
- City of Apple Valley: Natural Resources Management Permit
- City of Eagan: odd/even watering