The short version
- A bid you can compare has quantities on it: square feet, base depth, wall height, plant sizes. A single lump sum cannot be compared with anything.
- For patios, ask for excavation depth, base depth, and where the water goes in writing.
- For walls, ask for drain tile, backfill stone, reinforcement, and who pays for engineering and the permit.
- For plants, ask for sizes at planting and the warranty terms.
- Ask who will be on your property: employees or subcontractors.
First, make sure the bids describe the same job
Most price gaps between bids are scope gaps. One contractor priced a 14 by 20 patio with a six-inch base and drain tile. Another priced 14 by 18 with four inches and no drainage. Both wrote "paver patio" and a number.
Before comparing prices, put the bids side by side and check that each one states:
- Dimensions and square footage of each surface, and length and height of each wall.
- The exact product: manufacturer, paver or block name, and color.
- What is being removed and whether hauling it away is included.
- What happens to the lawn and beds the equipment crosses.
If a bid does not say, ask the contractor to add it. A contractor who will not put it in writing has told you something useful.
Patio and walkway bids
| Line | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Excavation | Depth in inches, and haul-off included. |
| Base | Depth and material. The industry guide sets a minimum of 4 inches under patios and walks and 6 inches under driveways, and more in cold climates and weak or wet soils. |
| Compaction | Compacted in layers, with a plate compactor sized for the job. |
| Fabric | Geotextile between soil and base where the soil is soft or holds water. |
| Edge restraint | Type, and how it is anchored. Edges are where patios spread first. |
| Slope and drainage | Which way the surface drains and any drain tile or catch basin. |
| Joints | Polymeric sand or another named joint material. |
| Steps and transitions | How the patio meets the door threshold, existing walks, and the lawn. |
Ask whether the contractor photographs the base before it is covered. It is the only record you will ever have of the part that decides whether the patio stays flat. We send ours with the invoice.
Retaining wall bids
| Line | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Height and length | Total height including the buried course, since that is how the permit rule measures it. |
| Base | Compacted aggregate leveling pad, with depth and width stated. |
| Drainage | Drain tile at the base, clean stone behind the wall, and where the tile outlets. |
| Reinforcement | Geogrid layers and lengths on taller walls. Industry guidance has reinforcement extending back at least 0.6 times the wall height. |
| Engineering | Who hires the engineer and whether the fee is in the price. Required over four feet or with a surcharge. |
| Permit | Who files it and who meets the inspector. |
| Top of wall | Caps, and how surface water is kept from running over the face. |
Water is what pushes walls over. A wall bid with no drainage line is the first one to set aside.
Planting bids
- Sizes. Shrubs by container size, trees by caliper or height. "Three hydrangeas" can mean one-gallon or five-gallon plants, and the price difference is large.
- Species and cultivar. Named, so you can check hardiness. Much of the outer metro is still USDA zone 4b.
- Soil preparation. What is added and how deep the beds are worked.
- Mulch. Type and depth.
- Edging. Type and length.
- Warranty. How long, what it covers, and what voids it. Most plant warranties depend on watering, so ask how you will be shown what to do.
The company behind the bid
- Who does the work. Employees or subcontractors. Either can do good work, but you should know who is accountable and who is insured.
- Insurance. Ask for a certificate of general liability and workers' compensation, sent from the agent.
- Certification. For pavers and segmental walls, installer certification through the Concrete Masonry & Hardscapes Association (the body formed when ICPI and NCMA merged) shows the crew has been trained to the published standards.
- Pesticide license. Anyone applying weed control or fertilizer-with-herbicide for hire in Minnesota needs a commercial applicator license from the Department of Agriculture.
- Utility locates. The contractor should call 811 before digging.
- Warranty on workmanship. Length, and what it covers. Ours is one year.
- Who you call afterward. A company that also does maintenance will be back on your street.
Payment terms and changes
- Payment schedule. Tied to milestones you can see, such as materials delivered, base complete, and final walkthrough.
- Change orders. In writing, with a price, before the extra work is done.
- Unknowns. What happens if the crew finds buried debris, an unmarked line, or soil that will not compact. A good bid says how that is priced.
- Dates. A start window and an expected duration.
- Cleanup. How the site is left each evening and at the end.
Ten questions to ask every bidder
- How deep will you excavate, and how thick is the base?
- Where will the water go?
- Will you photograph the base before it is covered?
- Does this wall need a permit or engineering, and is that in your price?
- Are there easements on my lot, and does this design stay out of them?
- Who will be on site, and do they work for you?
- What sizes are the plants, and what is the warranty?
- What is not included?
- How do you price something unexpected?
- Can I see a job of yours that is at least three winters old?
The last question matters most in Minnesota. Almost any patio looks good in its first summer.
Common questions
Should I take the lowest landscaping bid?
How many bids should I get?
What is a reasonable deposit?
- Concrete Masonry & Hardscapes Association: interlocking concrete pavement construction guide
- Concrete Masonry & Hardscapes Association: segmental retaining wall design (SRW-TEC-004)
- Minnesota Rules 1300.0120: work exempt from permit
- Minnesota Department of Agriculture: pesticide applicator licensing
- USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map (2023)
- Gopher State One Call